What's my car worth after an accident in Utah?
After a crash, two numbers matter: what your car was worth right before the accident, and what it's worth now. The insurance company has its own number for both. Here's how to check yours.
The value before the accident is the starting point
If your car is a total loss, the insurance company pays its actual cash value: what a car like yours, with similar miles, equipment and condition, cost in your area right before the crash.
If your car can be repaired, that same value is the starting point to measure how much value it lost.
What raises or lowers your car's value
- Year, make, model and trim (for example, LX vs. EX-L).
- Mileage.
- Equipment and options, like 4x4, leather seats or a towing package.
- Condition before the accident, including maintenance and tires.
- Title history before the accident: a clean title is usually worth more than a rebuilt or salvage title.
- Your local market: prices in Utah can be different from national averages.
How insurers find comparable cars in Utah
For total-loss claims under your own policy, Utah rule R590-190-11 lets the insurer base the value on comparable cars available in the last 90 days, looking first in your local market and then in nearby areas.
The cash settlement must also cover applicable taxes, license fees and title transfer fees. Ask for the valuation report and check that the cars they used really match yours.
A repaired car can still be worth less
Even after a good repair, many buyers pay less for a car with an accident on its history report. That drop is called diminished value.
In Utah, when another driver caused the crash, the owner can claim the loss in market value in addition to the cost of repairs.
Check your car's value for free
Our free tool uses your VIN, mileage and Utah ZIP code to look for market data on similar cars. When there's enough evidence, it shows an estimate and the data behind it.
It is not an insurance appraisal. The insurer makes its own offer, and you can question it.
Keep these documents
- Photos of your car from before the accident.
- Maintenance and repair receipts.
- Receipts for upgrades, like new tires or a stereo.
- The insurer's valuation report and written offer.
- Listings of similar cars for sale near you.
Does the insurance company have to pay what a price guide says?
No. Price guides are a reference, but in a total loss the insurer usually uses its own report based on comparable cars. You can ask how they got the number and send evidence if it's low.
Can upgrades or new tires raise the value?
They can, if they make your car worth more than similar cars. Keep your receipts and ask the insurer to include them.
Does the value check cost anything?
No. The tools and information on this site are free for everyone, with or without a case, and you don't need to sign up.
Enable JavaScript to use the forms and check your vehicle.